top of page

Family Law and Domestic Violence: Scary Parenting and Informed Parenting Plans

Domestic violence (DV) extends its reach far beyond physical harm, affecting families in deeply profound ways. Understanding the importance of fear is crucial for family lawyers because it matters deeply when developing parenting plans. Fear, instilled by the 'scary' behaviors that define DV, creates an environment of uncertainty and anxiety, which significantly impacts the well-being of children. The Duluth power and control wheels serve as an important reference, depicting the broad spectrum of behaviors DV encompasses and highlighting how these behaviors contribute to an overarching environment of fear. Here’s why recognizing and addressing this 'scary' behavior is paramount in family law matters.

Fear in DV: Why It Matters for Children

At the core of domestic violence's (DV) impact is the creation of an environment that is fundamentally unsafe for children, be it emotionally or physically. Emotional safety becomes compromised when physical safety is threatened, as one cannot truly feel emotionally secure in the absence of physical safety. Yet, it is crucial to recognize emotional safety as a powerful and essential factor in a child's development. Children's innate need for safety and care from adults is deeply rooted, and in environments marred by scary and unpredictable behaviour, this foundation is shaken. Scary behaviour by a parent primes a child's nervous system to a state of vigilance, and overwhelming sense of anxiety. This heightened state of alertness diverts the brain's focus from learning and memory to survival, making it challenging for them to love, learn, and grow but also significantly interferes with their capacity to form emotional connections with others. Such children are inherently more vulnerable stress-related disorders, as their nervous systems remain perpetually on alert.

Early Exposure: The Impact of Fear on Infants:

Understanding the profound implications of scary behavior on a child's sense of physical and emotional safety sets the stage for a deeper exploration of its effects, particularly on the most vulnerable—infants and young children. It is a grave misconception to believe that infants and young children are shielded from the effects of DV due to their developmental stages. While early exposure to fear and unpredictability in the home may not lead to explicit memories, it significantly impacts an infant's developing emotional framework and activates their nervous system, and can leave lasting imprints on their ability to process emotions and manage stress as they develop.

Parenting Plans: Safeguarding Children's Well-Being

Given this understanding, the development of parenting plans takes on a new level of significance. It’s about more than schedules and responsibilities; it's about crafting an environment where children can feel secure, both physically and emotionally. This means considering how parenting arrangements can minimize exposure to 'scary' behaviors and ensure a stable, predictable environment that allows children’s nervous systems to calm and their emotional wounds to heal. Importantly, it also involves creating conditions where children are not continually exposed to such behaviors, actively preventing further harm. In this way, parenting plans become a critical tool in safeguarding children's well-being, ensuring they have the opportunity to grow in an environment free from fear and instability.

Family lawyers, therefore, play a crucial role in advocating for parenting plans that prioritize the child's emotional safety as much as their physical safety. By doing so, they help lay the groundwork for children to rebuild trust, reduce anxiety, and foster resilience, ensuring that their development can proceed unimpeded by the shadows of fear and uncertainty that DV casts.

Navigating Safety Within the Family Dynamic

In cases where a parent behaves in an intimidating manner or lacks emotional attunement, children often find themselves in a state of vigilance, assessing their safety within the family dynamic. For example, if a child is reluctant to leave the playground, a typical behavior driven by their desire to play more, a parent's angry reaction to a child not wanting to leave can inadvertently confirm the child's fears of being unsafe. Such reactions contribute to a feedback loop, reinforcing the child's need to continually assess for safety, as they navigate unpredictable and threatening parental responses.

The Cycle of Mistrust and the Search for Security

Children who have experienced scary and/or inconsistent responses from caregivers often carry a deep-seated mistrust, fundamentally altering how their brain perceives and responds to threats. They may feel compelled to test the trustworthiness of those around them repeatedly to build a sense of security. Unfortunately, parents who exhibit frightening behavior frequently fail to pass these tests of trust.

Implications for Parenting Plans

For children impacted by such experiences, gentle, conscious, and empathetic approaches to parenting are most effective and needed. However, these nurturing methods are often out of reach when a parent is frightening.

This reality has significant implications for the development of parenting plans in family law. The issue transcends mere differences in parenting styles, a common minimization in legal disputes. Acknowledging the profound impact of a parent's behavior on a child's sense of safety and well-being is essential.

Parenting plans should be crafted with an understanding that fostering emotional safety and trust is critical for the development of all children, but especially for those who have experienced environments marked by fear or a lack of emotional attunement. This nuanced approach recognizes that while every child benefits from supportive and understanding parenting, those who have been directly impacted by such adverse experiences require particular consideration to heal and thrive.

Related Blogs:

Have you visited

Co-Parenting College?



bottom of page